HR Meeting – Part 2: Return to Work and Subsequent Events
1. My return to work and Steve's comments
On Friday, October 23, my second working day after returning from my workplace injury with WSIB modified duties,
Steve called me into his office to talk about the job review.
The very first thing he said was:
"Do you know I cannot hire a new employee because you are taking the job?"
He then told me that my productivity numbers were low and he was watching my numbers from February.
He asked me how much longer I expected to remain on modified hours. I told him perhaps another two or three weeks, but I wasn't sure myself. And I told Steve, I was not sure.
The main subject of this conversation was that, as soon as my modified duties ended, I would be placed on another Personal Improvement Plan.
Steve said this would be probably my third PIP and that if I failed, the company would take further steps.
He also said that Brian would help me improve my performance.
After this conversation, Steve sent me a text message saying that I would receive help with improving my performance.
I was concerned because I had just returned from a workplace injury, and the first major discussion with my manager was about another PIP and possible consequences if I failed.
2. The photograph of my work bin
On the same day, my coworker Linda informed me that supervisor Bobby had secretly taken a photograph of me at my work area. I was packing orders at the same packing station with Linda.
I confronted Bobby in front of supervisor Flory.
Bobby laughed and explained that he had been taking a photograph of my bin.
I was wondering, why would Bobby take my picture and for what use.
3. My modified working hours on October 26
On Monday, October 26, I arrived at 10:00 a.m., according to my approved WSIB modified schedule of 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.
Brian questioned, he was at the packing stations, why I was starting at 10 am and said he was not aware of my schedule.
Approximately 20 minutes before my shift ended, he brought another cart to my packing station and told me to pack it.
Supervisor Flory later had to remove the cart.
4. My conversation with Steve about mutual separation
On Tuesday, October 27, considering the situation and my 22 years of service, I asked Steve whether we could discuss a mutually agreed separation of employment.
He immediately responded:
"No, no, no, you will not get any money!" "You will not get money, period."
He then asked whether I was resigning.
I clearly told him that I was not resigning. I was asking whether the company would consider a mutually agreed separation.
Steve then told me:
"In two or three weeks you will be placed on a PIP".
I was telling him, its not only money, how he says. It is about new faces, new energy. It happens, company wants new people, more exited, younger, active.
Then Steve says:
"The company doesn't want to pay you, the company wants to fire you if you fail the PIP. This is how the process works."
After the conversation, I sent Steve an email summarizing what we had discussed and asking him to forward it to Head Office.
He later confirmed by text message and verbally next day, that he had forwarded my email to the Head Office.
5. My concerns about the productivity records
I also want to explain a concern about my productivity calculations.
In March 2026, Steve proposed changing my regular working hours from 9:00 a.m.–5:30 p.m. to an evening shift of 11:30 a.m.–7:30 p.m. I declined that change.
Starting November 2, I began checking my daily productivity reports with Bobby.
I noticed that additional time was appearing in my recorded working hours:
November 2: one additional hour.
November 3: one additional hour.
November 5: an additional two hours and 17 minutes.
These additional hours affected my calculated productivity rate.
After I started asking for my productivity figures every day, the recorded hours appeared to be shorter with productivity going up.
And were accurate first time on Thursday, November 12, it was first time since we started to talk about my productivity few years ago.
I have the records.
6. What I am asking HR to review
Considering everything that happened, I am concerned about the way my employment situation has developed.
I would like HR to review:
My previous complaints about Brian.
The decisions surrounding my previous PIPs.
Steve's comments about another PIP and possible termination immediately after my return from injury.
The photograph of me.
The accuracy of my productivity records.
What do I want?
"Given my 22 years of service and the current situation, I would like to ask if the company would consider a mutually agreed separation of employment with a fair severance package."
Things are not the same anymore. Several events have happened, and they have changed how I see my future with Reliable Parts.
I have changed, and I no longer see my future with the company. That is why I decided to contact Human Resources directly and explain my concerns myself.
Perhaps Steve and Brian expected me to react as I had in the past — to stay quiet, accept the situation, or simply bring my concerns to Steve and leave it there. But this time, I decided to speak directly to Human Resources.
I want to be clear that I am not resigning. I am asking the company to consider a mutually agreed separation with fair financial compensation.

